Review – Walking Disaster by Jamie McGuire

walking-disaster[1]

DISASTER IS THE WORD!

Title: Walking Disaster
Author: Jamie McGuire
Pages: 433
Genre: New Adult – Romance
Reviewer: Nicole

Blurb:
Can you love someone too much?

Travis Maddox learned two things from his mother before she died: Love hard. Fight Harder.

In Walking Disaster, the life of Travis is full of fast women, underground gambling, and violence. But just when he thinks he is invincible, Abby Abernathy brings him to his knees.

Every story has two sides. In Beautiful Disaster, Abby had her say. Now it’s time to see the story through Travis’s eyes.

Review:
I have been anxiously counting down the days for Walking Disaster to be released, to read the re-tell of the beautiful story of Travis and Abby from Beautiful Disaster, but from Travis’s point of view. In Beautiful Disaster Abby and Travis captured my heart and it became one of my favorite books to date. I had such great expectations for this book but it pains me to say that Walking Disaster didn’t reach those expectations at all. Throughout my reading of the book I felt real disappointment as there were key moments from Beautiful Disaster that were either left out or glossed over, and when I finished the book, I was left feeling frustrated, disappointment and overall flat!

Walking Disaster is a re-tell of the story of Beautiful Disaster from Travis’s point of view. Travis Maddox, the youngest of five brothers, at the age of three lost his mother to cancer. Unfortunately, after his mother’s death his Dad didn’t handle the loss of his wife very well, so it was up to his older brothers to raise Travis. Now in collage, Travis – known as the “bad boy”, keeps his heart and emotions shielded at all times. He “bags” a lot of girls but forms no attachment and makes a living out of taking his inner turmoil of emotions and frustrations into fighting at an underground fighting ring called The Circle. It’s at one of his fights, that Abby makes a lasting impression on Travis. When he catches up with his cousin and roommate, Shepley, after the fight he discovers that Abby is actually the best friend of Shepley’s girlfriend, America. Abby is the first girl who doesn’t fall for Travis’s charm and for that he falls in love with her, leading Travis to fight for her attention and affection and to make Abby see she is in love with him too. Travis and Abby bring out the best and worst in each other and really have to fight to keep their relationship together.

The highlight about this story, in my opinion, was the prologue, presenting his mum’s final words to Travis. That really touched my heart. The Epilogue was also pleasantly surprising and very interesting causing me to wonder if this has anything to do with Jamie McGuire’s next installment in the Beautiful Disaster Series about Travis’s brother Thomas. Also the explanation and meaning behind what “Pigeon” means to Travis I found to be very unique and true.

One of the things that disappointed me most in Walking Disaster was the flow and overall content, certain parts of the book felt really rushed and just slopped together. I feel that Jamie McGuire focused a lot on insignificant and irrelevant details, such as the texting between Travis and Brazil? Then left out or glossed over some key moments between Abby and Travis from Beautiful Disaster. Moments such as; Travis knocking out Chris Jenks at lunch after discovering Abby and Travis are finally together and Abby has to settle Travis down, or when Abby dragged Travis into the lab room for some alone time, or when Travis asks Abby to come to his fight while on a date with Parker and then Abby getting attacked at that fight, or when Shepley and America were broken up but got back together at The Red. I believe if you are going to re-tell a story from the other characters point of view, then you need to re-tell the whole story with inclusions not deletions, because the reader already knows the story and is expecting and looking forward to reading certain scenes as experienced by the other character. I also felt the “inclusion” parts of the story was lacking as well. I wanted to know when and how Travis came to the conclusion of buying that engagement ring? I thought there would be more deep and meaning conversations about Travis’s feeling towards Abby with Shepley or his Dad or brother Trent. I guess overall I just wanted more.

I felt Abby, Shepley and America’s characters lacked depth in the re-telling of this story, versus Beautiful Disaster, in which all the characters came to life. I felt no real emotional connection to them this time. Abby was interesting to see through Travis eyes, but at times, if I didn’t know her side of the story she could come across as confusing…even misleading towards Travis. But it was Shepley’s character that was my biggest disappointment in this story, I thought he would be so much more of a lead player in the story from Travis’s point of view but I felt his presence was more rewarding, once again, in Beautiful Disaster.

What I did enjoy was being inside Travis’s head, to see his point of view, his understanding of the situation, his emotions and feelings…but I wanted more from him, more detail, just more of what I loved in Beautiful Disaster…

Overall I am sad to say, I will continue to rave on and recommend Beautiful Disaster to the world but Walking Disaster will be sadly not be mentioned.

lips grey 2.5

Check out review on Beautiful Disaster, Book #1 of the Beautiful Disaster series by Jamie McGuire

Advertisements

15 thoughts on “Review – Walking Disaster by Jamie McGuire

  1. The most memorable part of the book for me was when Travis broke down after Thanksgiving. It broke my heart. And yes, I do agree with your review about it feeling a bit rushed and some key points were not included in Travis’ POV.

    • Thank you for your comment, it’s great to get your feedback on the book! I know people LOVED the book but I guess that’s what so great reviews, it’s your personal point of view!

  2. Yep, I couldn’t understand her scene choices either – they made no friggin sense! And I felt like I should have been read Beautiful Disaster at the same time to fill in the gaps. It was disappointing.

  3. I am in love with the dual pov. I wonder if it would have made a difference if it was combined into 1 book? Nice touch adding the page count – always good to know beforehand (may have to steal that idea 😉

  4. I liked this book, more so because you saw past the ending of Beautiful Disaster that’s what saved it for me to give it a good review. But there were parts missing that was disappointing for me.

    • Thank you. I totally agree. Beautiful Disaster is one of my favourite books and i was so excited to read Walking Disaster, I think my expectations were way too high!

  5. Pingback: Review – Beautiful Disaster by Jamie McGuire | Book Gossips

  6. Pingback: BOOK GOSSIPS BEST REVIEWS FOR 2013! | Book Gossips

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s